O PRIMEIRO WEBINAR INTERNACIONAL MINDD–COTG FOI UM SUCESSO ! ASSISTA AOS VÍDEOS COMPLETOS DE “GOVERNANÇA DA IA E CIDADÃOS COMUNS” E TIRE SUAS PRÓPRIAS CONCLUSÕES Registro integral do Webinar

O PRIMEIRO WEBINAR INTERNACIONAL MINDD–COTG FOI UM SUCESSO !

ASSISTA AOS VÍDEOS COMPLETOS DO EVENTO: “GOVERNANÇA DA IA E CIDADÃOS COMUNS” apresentado por Scott Erik Stafne 

E  TIRE SUAS PRÓPRIAS CONCLUSÕES

Registro integral do Webinar

O Webinar original foi apresentado em inglês. Os vídeos também podem ser assistidos utilizando os recursos de acessibilidade linguística disponibilizados pelo YouTube, incluindo legendas traduzidas e, quando disponíveis, faixas adicionais de áudio em outros idiomas.

No sábado, 1º de agosto de 2026, às 10 horas da manhã, no Estado de Washington, Estados Unidos, foi realizado com sucesso, por meio da sala virtual de conferências do Zoom do MINDD, o Webinar Internacional MINDD–COTG Advocacy:

GOVERNANÇA DA IA E CIDADÃOS COMUNS : Compreendendo diferentes abordagens da Inteligência Artificial Apresentado por Scott Erik Stafne

Scott Erik Stafne, Advocate da The Church of the Gardens — COTG, desenvolveu o conteúdo do Webinar  com o auxílio de ferramentas de inteligência artificial, incluindo Todd AI e DeepSeek AI, e realizou a apresentação no ZOOM.

O Webinar abordou temas desenvolvidos por meio do trabalho de Scott sobre realidade, discernimento, governança da inteligência artificial e colaboração entre seres humanos e IA.

O evento foi organizado com o apoio tecnológico e operacional e com a participação de Marcia Almeida, Presidente do MINDD DEFENDA SEUS DIREITOS, do Rio de Janeiro, Brasil.

Billie Powers, convidada do programa Toll and Roll, da Califórnia, Estados Unidos, participou como apresentadora e contribuiu com suas próprias observações e preocupações durante o debate.

Participantes também se conectaram remotamente de diferentes localidades dos Estados Unidos e do Brasil.

UM WEBINAR PREPARADO E APRESENTADO EM TEMPO RECORDE

Scott Erik Stafne teve menos de quinze dias corridos para preparar e apresentar o Webinar, contados a partir da data em que aceitou o convite de Marcia Almeida para organizarem conjuntamente um evento internacional sobre o uso e os riscos da inteligência artificial no Direito.

O objetivo inicial foi posteriormente ampliado por Scott, que propôs começar pelas questões fundamentais relativas ao impacto da inteligência artificial sobre os cidadãos e a sociedade.

O conteúdo foi então desenvolvido ainda mais após considerações adicionais apresentadas por Marcia Almeida. Durante a semana do evento, o escopo foi novamente ampliado para incluir a criação da WAICO — World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization e as diferentes abordagens internacionais para a governança da inteligência artificial.

Apesar do período extremamente curto de preparação e da amplitude do tema, Scott preparou e realizou uma apresentação segura, firme, clara e abrangente, compatível com os objetivos do evento.

O Webinar foi realizado:

na data programada;

no horário programado;

dentro da duração planejada;

com a apresentação completa dos slides;

com a participação dos convidados;

e com debate entre os presentes.

A avaliação geral do evento foi muito positiva.

PRODUZIDO COM O AUXÍLIO DA INTELIGÊNCIA ARTIFICIAL

O conteúdo do Webinar, as imagens dos slides, a apresentação em PowerPoint, os materiais promocionais, os artigos bilíngues, a campanha de divulgação e a infraestrutura tecnológica foram desenvolvidos com o auxílio de ferramentas de inteligência artificial.

Scott Erik Stafne desenvolveu o conteúdo substantivo do Webinar e conduziu a apresentação a partir de seu computador desktop, em Arlington, Estado de Washington, utilizando o PowerPoint no ambiente Zoom.

Marcia Almeida produziu imagens adicionais de abertura e encerramento, montou a apresentação em PowerPoint, criou materiais promocionais e artigos em inglês e português, organizou a campanha de divulgação e configurou o ambiente do Zoom utilizando ferramentas tecnológicas e recursos do ChatGPT por meio de um celular Samsung Android.

A apresentação em PowerPoint, os materiais promocionais, a infraestrutura do Zoom e a campanha de divulgação foram montados e implementados em um período excepcionalmente curto.

Isso torna o resultado ainda mais significativo, considerando que foi a primeira vez que Scott e Marcia organizaram e realizaram conjuntamente um Webinar internacional nesse formato.

PRINCIPAIS TEMAS ABORDADOS

Scott Erik Stafne discutiu como cidadãos comuns, usuários finais e pessoas que não controlam grandes corporações de tecnologia podem compreender, utilizar e avaliar criticamente a inteligência artificial.

A relação entre os cidadãos e a Inteligência Artificial

Scott argumentou que os usuários devem desenvolver uma relação investigativa com a IA, utilizando-a como ferramenta de pesquisa, reflexão e debate, sem confiar cegamente nas respostas que ela produz.

Os usuários devem preservar seu próprio discernimento, verificar os fatos, conferir as fontes e reconhecer que os sistemas de IA podem gerar informações imprecisas.

Diferentes modelos internacionais de governança

A apresentação examinou diferentes abordagens adotadas ou discutidas por países e blocos internacionais, incluindo:

os Estados Unidos;

a China;

o Brasil;

a União Europeia;

e a criação da WAICO.

Scott explicou que diferentes modelos podem enfatizar prioridades distintas, incluindo direitos individuais, desenvolvimento econômico, segurança, inovação, controle estatal, cooperação internacional ou domínio tecnológico.

Direitos, responsabilidades e transparência

O Webinar enfatizou que direitos fortes para os cidadãos devem ser acompanhados por responsabilidades claras dos governos, das corporações, dos desenvolvedores e dos operadores dos sistemas de inteligência artificial.

Também enfatizou a necessidade de transparência, supervisão e mecanismos por meio dos quais as decisões possam ser contestadas e as consequências prejudiciais possam ser corrigidas.

O papel dos cidadãos comuns

Um dos pontos centrais do Webinar foi a necessidade de impedir que o desenvolvimento e a governança da inteligência artificial permaneçam exclusivamente concentrados nas mãos de governos, corporações, especialistas técnicos e grandes grupos econômicos.

Os cidadãos comuns, os usuários finais e as comunidades afetadas devem participar ativamente da definição dos objetivos, das limitações, das responsabilidades e das condições que regem o uso dessas tecnologias.

Inteligência Artificial, Justiça e Direitos Humanos

O Webinar também manifestou preocupação com a incorporação da inteligência artificial aos sistemas jurídicos sem supervisão adequada.

A discussão abordou riscos envolvendo informações falsas, precedentes inexistentes, respostas não verificadas e sistemas capazes de reforçar erros, preconceitos, classificações injustas ou estruturas institucionais de poder.

Discernimento humano e inteligência original

A mensagem final enfatizou que a inteligência humana original — formada pela experiência, memória, história, consciência, valores e discernimento — não deve ser substituída por sistemas automatizados.

A inteligência artificial deve servir à humanidade, à dignidade humana, aos direitos fundamentais e ao bem comum.

PARTICIPAÇÃO E DEBATE

Durante a parte final do Webinar, os participantes compartilharam experiências pessoais e reflexões sobre o uso da inteligência artificial.

Billie Powers também apresentou suas próprias preocupações e observações, enquanto o diálogo com Debb e os demais participantes ampliou as dimensões práticas e humanas do evento.

O debate demonstrou que os cidadãos já possuem experiências concretas capazes de contribuir para o desenvolvimento e a governança responsáveis da IA.

ASSISTA À GRAVAÇÃO ORIGINAL DO ZOOM

O vídeo original gravado por meio do Zoom foi publicado no canal de Marcia Almeida no YouTube no mesmo dia, 1º de agosto de 2026.

WEBINAR INTERNACIONAL: GOVERNANÇA DA IA E CIDADÃOS COMUNS

Compreendendo diferentes abordagens da Inteligência Artificial com Scott Erik Stafne

Data: sábado, 1º de agosto de 2026

Assista à gravação original do Webinar no Zoom:

https://youtu.be/_z8GnrIEib4?is=pq-MlEiNhvw0meY3

A gravação original é apresentada em inglês.

 Os espectadores também podem utilizar os recursos de acessibilidade linguística disponibilizados pelo YouTube, incluindo legendas traduzidas e, quando disponíveis, faixas adicionais de áudio.

ASSISTA À VERSÃO DO POWERPOINT EM TELA CHEIA

No dia seguinte ao evento, Marcia Almeida criou uma segunda versão do Webinar utilizando a gravação original completa produzida pelo Zoom.

Nessa versão, o áudio original completo do Webinar foi sincronizado com os slides do PowerPoint de Scott Erik Stafne, exibidos em tela cheia para facilitar a leitura e a visualização.

Esse vídeo foi criado inteiramente por meio de um celular Android, com o auxílio do ChatGPT, que apoiou o processo de edição e sincronização audiovisual.

Essa experiência demonstra, na prática, o potencial da inteligência artificial para permitir que usuários comuns, sem treinamento profissional em edição de vídeo ou equipamentos especializados, produzam projetos audiovisuais complexos.

A versão do PowerPoint em tela cheia é apresentada em inglês e também pode ser assistida utilizando os recursos de acessibilidade linguística disponibilizados pelo YouTube.

Assista à versão com áudio e PowerPoint em tela cheia:

https://youtu.be/1LwjlpSg3V0?is=Aybnkqvh3KV58Klw

UM CASO EMPÍRICO DE PARTICIPAÇÃO DOS USUÁRIOS FINAIS

Todo o processo de criação, organização, apresentação, gravação e edição do Webinar constitui um caso empírico sobre o papel dos usuários finais no desenvolvimento e no uso da inteligência artificial.

A experiência demonstra que cidadãos comuns podem:

aprender a utilizar novas tecnologias;

produzir conhecimento;

identificar limitações;

verificar informações;

desenvolver materiais educacionais;

participar de debates internacionais;

e contribuir para a definição dos requisitos éticos, jurídicos, sociais e tecnológicos da inteligência artificial.

UMA OPORTUNIDADE PARA AMPLIAR O DEBATE INTERNACIONAL

Uma oportunidade para ampliar o debate internacional

A relevância do Webinar tornou-se ainda mais evidente em 4 de agosto de 2026, quando Marcia Almeida recebeu, por meio do Academia.edu, um comentário acadêmico sobre a confiabilidade e a governança da inteligência artificial agêntica.

Comentário: Qi, J. et al. Rumo a uma inteligência artificial agêntica confiável: uma pesquisa abrangente sobre segurança, robustez, privacidade e segurança dos sistemas. Acad. AI Appl. 2026, 2, 8260, por Anastasios Stavropoulos.

Leia o comentário no Academia.edu:

https://www.academia.edu/3071-0286/2/3/10.20935/AcadAI8435

O comentário de Anastasios Stavropoulos e o estudo de Jinhu Qi e seus coautores convidam pesquisadores, profissionais, usuários e membros da sociedade a contribuir para discussões sobre:

• segurança;
• robustez;
• privacidade;
• segurança dos sistemas;
• responsabilização;
• supervisão coletiva;
• riscos emergentes;
• métricas de avaliação;
• casos empíricos;
• e a participação da sociedade na governança da inteligência artificial.

Essas questões convergem diretamente com o conteúdo apresentado por Scott Erik Stafne durante o Webinar e reforçam a importância da participação dos cidadãos comuns e dos usuários finais.

O WEBINAR FOI UM SUCESSO

O Webinar Internacional MINDD–COTG Advocacy foi realizado com sucesso na data programada, no horário programado e dentro da duração planejada.

Scott Erik Stafne realizou a apresentação formal sem interrupções técnicas. Ele apresentou integralmente seu trabalho, transmitiu seus conhecimentos com clareza e segurança, exibiu os slides, participou dos debates e respondeu às contribuições dos presentes.

O evento demonstrou que a cooperação internacional, a participação cidadã e o uso consciente da inteligência artificial podem ampliar o acesso ao conhecimento e contribuir para a proteção da dignidade humana, dos direitos fundamentais e de uma governança tecnológica responsável.

Parabéns a Scott Erik Stafne, Billie Powers e a todos os participantes que estiveram presentes no evento.

ASSISTA, COMENTE, COMPARTILHE E PARTICIPE DO DEBATE

Convidamos pesquisadores, profissionais, organizações da sociedade civil, desenvolvedores, usuários finais e cidadãos de todos os países a:

assistir aos dois vídeos do Webinar;

utilizar as opções de idioma disponíveis de sua preferência;

compartilhar suas experiências;

enviar comentários;

participar do debate internacional;

e integrar o movimento internacional MINDD–COTG Advocacy.

A inteligência artificial afetará toda a humanidade. Portanto, seu desenvolvimento e sua governança não podem ocorrer sem a participação das pessoas que utilizarão essas tecnologias e vivenciarão diretamente suas consequências.

Depois de assistir à apresentação completa no YouTube, gratuitamente, os espectadores poderão considerar a seguinte pergunta e participar desta colaboração internacional:

> O primeiro Webinar Internacional MINDD–COTG foi um sucesso ?

COMENTÁRIOS RECEBIDOS POR MEIO DO ACADEMIA.EDU

Também recebemos mensagens interessantes por meio do Academia.edu sobre a colaboração intitulada:

> “Do planejamento de um seminário à prática do discernimento: colaborações entre seres humanos e IA na preparação de uma conversa internacional sobre governança da IA.”

https://www.academia.edu/171062696/_From_Planning_a_Seminar_to_Practicing_Discernment_Human_AI_Collaborations_Preparing_an_International_Conversation_on_AI_Governance_By_Scott_Erik_Stafne_in_collaboration_with_Todd_AI_an_instance_of_ChatGPT_and_DeekSeek_July_29_31_2026_

Aqui está uma delas, de Edervaldo J. S. Melo:

Edervaldo J. S. Melo — Universidade Federal de Mato Grosso — UFMT

Prezado Scott,

Parabéns por esta publicação. O que considero especialmente valioso aqui é que o artigo não discute meramente a colaboração humano–IA a partir de uma perspectiva externa; ele documenta o processo a partir de dentro, preservando as hesitações, comparações, revisões e atos de discernimento que normalmente desaparecem dos textos acadêmicos concluídos.

Nesse sentido, o trabalho torna-se mais do que um relatório sobre a preparação de um seminário. Ele também constitui um estudo de caso sobre como o julgamento humano, múltiplos sistemas de IA e intercâmbios acadêmicos internacionais podem interagir sem reduzir o participante humano à condição de usuário passivo.

Sinto-me honrado pelo fato de nosso artigo, “Quem observa quem no zoológico humano?”, ter se tornado parte dessa conversa mais ampla. Espero que esse diálogo continue crescendo como uma investigação interdisciplinar aberta sobre governança da IA, soberania cognitiva e preservação do discernimento humano.

Com apreço,

Edervaldo J. S. Melo

Josep Antoni Herrera Sancho, Ph.D., escreveu:

> “Parabéns por esta publicação!”

Participe deste debate público, comente e compartilhe os vídeos e os artigos publicados por Scott Erik Stafne no Academia.edu.

Agradecemos por ler, assistir e participar.

WAS the First MINDD-COTG International Seminar a Success? Scott Erik Stafne, Todd AI, and DeepSeek Reflecting on Reality, Discernment, and Human–AI Collaboration By Scott Erik Stafne in collaboration with Todd AI and DeepSeek AI (August 1 - 3, 2026) Scott E Stafne, Watch the original Webinar Records on ZOOM on YouTube !

Was the First MINDD-COTG International Seminar a Success !

 Full record of the WEBINAR 

With AUDIO in 

ENGLISH ( original) 

FRANCH , GERMAN, SPANISH, etc...

Scott Erik Stafne developed the Webinar’s substantive content with the assistance of Todd AI and DeepSeek AI, and delivered the principal presentation on ZOOM VIRTUAL CONFERENCE HALL. 

Marcia Almeida developed the additional visual materials, assembled the PowerPoint presentation, prepared the bilingual promotional articles and outreach materials, and configured the Zoom technological infrastructure with the assistance of ChatGPT.

WATCH  the  FULL RECORDS of  the ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE GOVERNANCE WEBINAR’S  on YOU TUBE and see by yourself 

The WEBINAR’S  PowerPoint presentation and the overal technological  infrastructure and marketing campaign was developed  and deployed - just in time - in less thant  2 ( two) days 

On Saturday, August 1, 2026, at 10:00 a.m. in Washington State, United States, the MINDD–COTG Advocacy International Webinar 

"AI GOVERNANCE AND ORDINARY CITIZENS

Understanding Different Approaches to Artificial Intelligence"  by Scott Erik Stafne was successfully held on  MINDD's Zoom Conference Hall :

The Webinar was presented by Scott Erik Stafne, Advocate of The Church of the Gardens — COTG, from Arlington, Washington State, United States, 

with the  technological infrastructure, organization and participation of Marcia Almeida, President of MINDD DEFEND YOUR RIGHTS, from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, and the presentation and participation of Billie Powers, invited guest, from Toll and Roll, California, United States.

Participants also joined remotely from different locations in the United States and Brazil.

A Webinar Prepared and delivered in Record Time

Scott Erik Stafne had fewer than fifteen calendar days to prepare and present the Webinar, beginning on the date when he accepted Marcia Almeida’s invitation to jointly organize an international event concerning the use and risks of artificial intelligence in Law.

The initial objective was subsequently expanded by Scott, who proposed beginning with the fundamental questions concerning the impact of artificial intelligence on citizens and society.

The content was then further developed and expanded following new considerations presented by Marcia Almeida and, during the week of the event, because of the need to include the creation of WAICO — World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization and the different international approaches to artificial intelligence governance.

Despite the extremely short preparation period and the breadth of the subject, Scott prepared and delivered a confident, firm, clear, and comprehensive presentation within the proposed objectives.

The Webinar was held:

on the scheduled date;

at the scheduled time;

within the planned duration;

with the complete presentation of the slides;

with the participation of the invited guests;

and with discussion among those present.

The overall evaluation of the event was very positive.

Everything Produced with the Assistance of Artificial Intelligence

The intellectual content, slide images, PowerPoint presentation, flyers, articles,  propaganda and all the ZOOM event’s technological infrastructure were developed with the assistance of artificial intelligence tools.

Scott Erik Stafne  developed and conducted the presentation from his desktop computer in Arlington, Washington State, using the PowerPoint prsentation within the Zoom environment.

Marcia Almeida produced additional opening and closing images, assembled the PowerPoint presentation, organized  and developed the flyers, the articles, in English and Portuguese, of the publicity campaign, and configured the Zoom environment using technological tools and ChatGPT resources through a Samsung Android mobile phone.

All preparations were completed in record time. 

This makes the result even more significant, considering that it was the first time Scott and Marcia had jointly organized and conducted an international Webinar in this format.

Main Topics Addressed

Scott Erik Stafne discussed how ordinary citizens, end users, and people who do not control major technology corporations can understand, use, and critically evaluate artificial intelligence.

The principal topics included:

The Relationship Between Citizens and Artificial Intelligence

Scott argued that users should develop an investigative relationship with AI, using it as a tool for research, reflection, and debate without blindly trusting the answers it produces.

Users must preserve their own discernment, verify facts, check sources, and recognize that AI systems can generate inaccurate information.

Different International Governance Models

The presentation examined different approaches adopted or discussed by countries and international blocs, including:

the United States;

China;

Brazil;

the European Union;

and the creation of WAICO.

Scott explained that different models may emphasize different priorities, including individual rights, economic development, safety, innovation, state control, international cooperation, or technological dominance.

Rights, Responsibilities, and Transparency

The Webinar emphasized that strong rights for citizens must be accompanied by clear responsibilities for governments, corporations, developers, and operators of artificial intelligence systems.

It also emphasized the need for transparency, oversight, and mechanisms through which decisions can be challenged and harmful consequences corrected.

The Role of Ordinary Citizens

One of the Webinar’s central points was the need to prevent the development and governance of artificial intelligence from remaining exclusively concentrated in the hands of governments, corporations, technical experts, and major economic groups.

Ordinary citizens, end users, and affected communities must actively participate in defining the objectives, limitations, responsibilities, and conditions governing the use of these technologies.

Artificial Intelligence, Justice, and Human Rights

The Webinar also expressed concern about incorporating artificial intelligence into legal systems without adequate oversight.

The discussion addressed risks involving false information, nonexistent precedents, unverified responses, and systems capable of reinforcing errors, prejudices, unjust classifications, or institutional structures of power.

Human Discernment and Original Intelligence

The final message emphasized that original human intelligence — formed by experience, memory, history, conscience, values, and discernment — must not be replaced by automated systems.

Artificial intelligence must serve humanity, human dignity, fundamental rights, and the common good.

Participation and Discussion

During the final part of the Webinar, participants shared personal experiences and reflections concerning the use of artificial intelligence.

Billie Powers also presented her own concerns and observations, while the dialogue with Debb and the other participants expanded the practical and human dimensions of the event.

The discussion demonstrated that citizens already possess concrete experiences capable of contributing to the responsible development and governance of AI.

WATCH THE ORIGINAL ZOOM WEBINAR VIDEO

The original video recorded through Zoom was published on Marcia Almeida’s YouTube channel on the same day, August 1, 2026.

INTERNATIONAL WEBINAR: AI GOVERNANCE AND ORDINARY CITIZENS

Understanding Different Approaches to Artificial Intelligence with Scott Erik Stafne on Zoom

Date: Saturday, August 1, 2026

Watch the original  ZOOM's record  of the Webinar:

https://youtu.be/_z8GnrIEib4?is=pq-MlEiNhvw0meY3

The Webinar video is available in English and also offers audio in other languages, allowing viewers to follow the presentation in their preferred language, according to the language options made available by YouTube.

WATCH THE FULL-SCREEN POWERPOINT VERSION

On the day following the event, Marcia Almeida created a second version of the Webinar using the complete original recording produced by Zoom.

In this version, the complete original Webinar audio was synchronized with Scott Erik Stafne’s PowerPoint slides, which are displayed in full screen to facilitate reading and viewing.

This new video was CREATED only on an Android mobile phone with the assistance of ChatGPT, which was used as a tool to support audiovisual editing and synchronization.

This experience demonstrates, in practice, the potential of artificial intelligence to enable ordinary users without professional video-editing training or specialized equipment to produce complex audiovisual projects.

The full-screen PowerPoint version is also available with audio in other languages, in addition to English, according to the language options provided by YouTube.

The link of the full-screen AUDIO and POWERPOINT only is :

https://youtu.be/1LwjlpSg3V0?is=Aybnkqvh3KV58Klw

An Empirical Case of End-User Participation

The entire process of creating, organizing, presenting, recording, and editing the Webinar constitutes an empirical case concerning the role of end users in the development and use of artificial intelligence.

The experience demonstrates that ordinary citizens can:

learn to use new technologies;

produce knowledge;

identify limitations;

verify information;

develop educational materials;

participate in international debates;

and contribute to defining the ethical, legal, social, and technological requirements of artificial intelligence.

An Opportunity to Expand the International Debate

The relevance of the Webinar became even clearer on August 4, 2026, when Marcia Almeida received through Academia.edu an article concerning the trustworthiness and governance of agentic artificial intelligence.

Commentary: Qi, J. et al. Towards trustworthy agentic AI: a comprehensive survey of safety, robustness, privacy, and system security. Acad. AI Appl. 2026, 2, 8260 by Anastasios Stavropoulos* [1,2]

The commentary by Anastasios Stavropoulos and the study by Jinhu Qi and his coauthors invite researchers, professionals, users, and members of society to contribute to discussions concerning:

safety;

robustness;

privacy;

system security;

accountability;

collective oversight;

emerging risks;

evaluation metrics;

empirical cases;

and society’s participation in artificial intelligence governance.

These questions converge directly with the content presented by Scott Erik Stafne during the Webinar and reinforce the importance of the participation of ordinary citizens and end users.

 

THE WEBINAR WAS A SUCCESS ? 

The MINDD–COTG Advocacy International Webinar was successfully conducted on the scheduled date, at the scheduled time, and within the planned duration, without any thecnological issue !

Scott Erik Stafne presented his work in full, communicated his knowledge clearly and confidently, displayed the slides, participated in the discussions, and responded to the contributions of those present.

The event demonstrated that international cooperation, citizen participation, and the conscious use of artificial intelligence can expand access to knowledge and contribute to the protection of human dignity, fundamental rights, and responsible technological governance.

Congratulations to Scott Erik Stafne, Billie Powers, and all the participants who attended the event.

WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE, AND JOIN THE DEBATE

We invite researchers, professionals, civil society organizations, developers, end users, and citizens from all countries to:

watch both Webinar videos;

select the available audio language of their choice;

share their experiences;

submit comments;

participate in the international debate;

and join the MINDD–COTG Advocacy international movement.

Artificial intelligence will affect all humanity. Its development and governance therefore cannot take place without the participation of the people who will use these technologies and directly experience their consequences.

After you watch the full lecture on YOUTUBE  - free of charges - you will be able to answers this Question and join this international collaboration 

Was the First MINDD-COTG International Seminar a Success?  Click here to read  Scott's  original article on Academia.edu 

COMMENTS RECEIVED THROUGH ACADEMIA.EDU

We also received some interesting emails in our Academia.edu messages regarding our collaboration entitled “From Planning a Seminar to Practicing Discernment: Human-AI Collaborations Preparing an International Conversation on AI Governance.”

Here is one of them, from Edervaldo J. S. Melo:

Edervaldo J. S. Melo — 6:00 p.m. — Federal University of Mato Grosso (UFMT)

Dear Scott,

Congratulations on this publication. What I find especially valuable here is that the article does not merely discuss human–AI collaboration from an external perspective; it documents the process from within, preserving the hesitations, comparisons, revisions, and acts of discernment that normally disappear from completed academic texts.

In this sense, the work becomes more than a report on the preparation of a seminar. It also constitutes a case study of how human judgment, multiple AI systems, and international academic exchanges can interact without reducing the human participant to the condition of a passive user.

I feel honored that our article, “Who Observes Whom in the Human Zoo?”, became part of this broader conversation. I hope that this dialogue will continue to grow as an open interdisciplinary inquiry into AI governance, cognitive sovereignty, and the preservation of human discernment.

With appreciation,

Edervaldo J. S. Melo

Scott:

Josep Antoni Herrera Sancho, Ph.D., wrote: “Congratulations on this publication!”

Join this PUBLIC debate,  comment, and share the vídeos, and the  development  articles Published by Scott Erik Stafne on Academia.edu. 

Thank you for readind,  watching and participating ! 

MINDD - COTG ADVOCACY AI WEBINAR: WATCH THE VIDEOS OF THE INTERNATIONAL AI WEBINAR: AI GOVERNANCE AND ORDINARY CITIZENS On Saturday, August 1, 2026, at 10:00 a.m. in Washington State, United States, the MINDD–COTG Advocacy International Webinar by Scott Erik Stafne

 

 ORIGINAL WEBINAR INTERNACIONAL 

WATCH THE VIDEOS OF THE  INTERNATIONAL AI WEBINAR: AI GOVERNANCE AND ORDINARY CITIZENS by SCOTT ERIK STAFNE 

On Saturday, August 1, 2026, at 10:00 a.m. in Washington State, United States, the MINDD–COTG Advocacy International Webinar was successfully held:

AI GOVERNANCE AND ORDINARY CITIZENS

Understanding Different Approaches to Artificial Intelligence

The Webinar was presented by Scott Erik Stafne, Advocate of The Church of the Gardens — COTG, from Arlington, Washington State, United States, with the organization and participation of Marcia Almeida, President of MINDD DEFEND YOUR RIGHTS, from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, and the presentation and participation of Billie Powers, from Toll and Roll, California, United States.

Participants also joined remotely from different locations in the United States and Brazil.

A Webinar Prepared in Record Time

Scott Erik Stafne had fewer than fifteen calendar days to prepare and present the Webinar, beginning on the date when he accepted Marcia Almeida’s invitation to jointly organize an international event concerning the use and risks of artificial intelligence in Law.

The initial objective was subsequently expanded by Scott, who proposed beginning with the fundamental questions concerning the impact of artificial intelligence on citizens and society.

The content was then further developed and expanded following new considerations presented by Marcia Almeida and, during the week of the event, because of the need to include the creation of WAICO — World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization and the different international approaches to artificial intelligence governance.

Despite the extremely short preparation period and the breadth of the subject, Scott prepared and delivered a confident, firm, clear, and comprehensive presentation within the proposed objectives.

The Webinar was held:

on the scheduled date;

at the scheduled time;

within the planned duration;

with the complete presentation of the slides;

with the participation of the invited guests;

and with discussion among those present.

The overall evaluation of the event was very positive.

Produced with the Assistance of Artificial Intelligence

The intellectual content, slide images, PowerPoint presentation, and part of the event’s technological infrastructure were developed with the assistance of artificial intelligence tools.

Scott Erik Stafne conducted the presentation from his desktop computer in Arlington, Washington State, using PowerPoint within the Zoom environment.

Marcia Almeida produced additional opening and closing images, assembled the PowerPoint presentation, organized the publicity campaign, and configured the Zoom environment using technological tools and ChatGPT resources through a Samsung Android mobile phone.

All preparations were completed in record time. This makes the result even more significant, considering that it was the first time Scott and Marcia had jointly organized and conducted an international Webinar in this format.

Main Topics Addressed

Scott Erik Stafne discussed how ordinary citizens, end users, and people who do not control major technology corporations can understand, use, and critically evaluate artificial intelligence.

The principal topics included:

The Relationship Between Citizens and Artificial Intelligence

Scott argued that users should develop an investigative relationship with AI, using it as a tool for research, reflection, and debate without blindly trusting the answers it produces.

Users must preserve their own discernment, verify facts, check sources, and recognize that AI systems can generate inaccurate information.

Different International Governance Models

The presentation examined different approaches adopted or discussed by countries and international blocs, including:

the United States;

China;

Brazil;

the European Union;

and the creation of WAICO.

Scott explained that different models may emphasize different priorities, including individual rights, economic development, safety, innovation, state control, international cooperation, or technological dominance.

Rights, Responsibilities, and Transparency

The Webinar emphasized that strong rights for citizens must be accompanied by clear responsibilities for governments, corporations, developers, and operators of artificial intelligence systems.

It also emphasized the need for transparency, oversight, and mechanisms through which decisions can be challenged and harmful consequences corrected.

The Role of Ordinary Citizens

One of the Webinar’s central points was the need to prevent the development and governance of artificial intelligence from remaining exclusively concentrated in the hands of governments, corporations, technical experts, and major economic groups.

Ordinary citizens, end users, and affected communities must actively participate in defining the objectives, limitations, responsibilities, and conditions governing the use of these technologies.

Artificial Intelligence, Justice, and Human Rights

The Webinar also expressed concern about incorporating artificial intelligence into legal systems without adequate oversight.

The discussion addressed risks involving false information, nonexistent precedents, unverified responses, and systems capable of reinforcing errors, prejudices, unjust classifications, or institutional structures of power.

Human Discernment and Original Intelligence

The final message emphasized that original human intelligence — formed by experience, memory, history, conscience, values, and discernment — must not be replaced by automated systems.

Artificial intelligence must serve humanity, human dignity, fundamental rights, and the common good.

Participation and Discussion

During the final part of the Webinar, participants shared personal experiences and reflections concerning the use of artificial intelligence.

Billie Powers also presented her own concerns and observations, while the dialogue with Debb and the other participants expanded the practical and human dimensions of the event.

The discussion demonstrated that citizens already possess concrete experiences capable of contributing to the responsible development and governance of AI.

WATCH THE ORIGINAL ZOOM WEBINAR VIDEO

The original video recorded through Zoom was published on Marcia Almeida’s YouTube channel on the same day, August 1, 2026.

INTERNATIONAL WEBINAR: AI GOVERNANCE AND ORDINARY CITIZENS

Understanding Different Approaches to Artificial Intelligence with Scott Erik Stafne on Zoom

Date: Saturday, August 1, 2026

Watch the original Webinar:

https://youtu.be/_z8GnrIEib4?is=pq-MlEiNhvw0meY3

The original Webinar video is available in English and also offers audio in other languages, allowing viewers to follow the presentation in their preferred language, according to the language options made available by YouTube.

WATCH THE FULL-SCREEN POWERPOINT VERSION

On the day following the event, Marcia Almeida created a second version of the Webinar using the complete original recording produced by Zoom.

In this version, the complete original Webinar audio was synchronized with Scott Erik Stafne’s PowerPoint slides, which are displayed in full screen to facilitate reading and viewing.

The work was completed on an Android mobile phone with the assistance of ChatGPT, which was used as a tool to support audiovisual editing and synchronization.

This experience demonstrates, in practice, the potential of artificial intelligence to enable ordinary users without professional video-editing training or specialized equipment to produce complex audiovisual projects.

The full-screen PowerPoint version is also available with audio in other languages, in addition to English, according to the language options provided by YouTube.

Watch the full-screen AUDIO and POWERPOINT only:

https://youtu.be/1LwjlpSg3V0?is=Aybnkqvh3KV58Klw

An Empirical Case of End-User Participation

The entire process of creating, organizing, presenting, recording, and editing the Webinar constitutes an empirical case concerning the role of end users in the development and use of artificial intelligence.

The experience demonstrates that ordinary citizens can:

learn to use new technologies;

produce knowledge;

identify limitations;

verify information;

develop educational materials;

participate in international debates;

and contribute to defining the ethical, legal, social, and technological requirements of artificial intelligence.

An Opportunity to Expand the International Debate

The relevance of the Webinar became even clearer on August 4, 2026, when Marcia Almeida received through Academia.edu an article concerning the trustworthiness and governance of agentic artificial intelligence.

The commentary by Anastasios Stavropoulos and the study by Jinhu Qi and his coauthors invite researchers, professionals, users, and members of society to contribute to discussions concerning:

safety;

robustness;

privacy;

system security;

accountability;

collective oversight;

emerging risks;

evaluation metrics;

empirical cases;

and society’s participation in artificial intelligence governance.

These questions converge directly with the content presented by Scott Erik Stafne during the Webinar and reinforce the importance of the participation of ordinary citizens and end users.

THE WEBINAR WAS A SUCCESS

The MINDD–COTG Advocacy International Webinar was successfully conducted on the scheduled date, at the scheduled time, and within the planned duration.

Scott Erik Stafne presented his work in full, communicated his knowledge clearly and confidently, displayed the slides, participated in the discussions, and responded to the contributions of those present.

The event demonstrated that international cooperation, citizen participation, and the conscious use of artificial intelligence can expand access to knowledge and contribute to the protection of human dignity, fundamental rights, and responsible technological governance.

Congratulations to Scott Erik Stafne, Billie Powers, and all the participants who attended the event.

WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE, AND JOIN THE DEBATE

We invite researchers, professionals, civil society organizations, developers, end users, and citizens from all countries to:

watch both Webinar videos;

select the available audio language of their choice;

share their experiences;

submit comments;

participate in the international debate;

and join the MINDD–COTG Advocacy international movement.

Artificial intelligence will affect all humanity. Its development and governance therefore cannot take place without the participation of the people who will use these technologies and directly experience their consequences.

Divine Justice and the Penal Code of the Future Life: An Educational Perspective of Existence : "Do we live in a universe governed by punishments or by a perfect process of spiritual education?" by Judge Haroldo Dutra Dias

"JESUS, I TRUST IN YOU"

"Every soul that believes and trusts in My mercy will attain it. — (Diary of St. Faustina, 420)

Whoever does not want to pass through the door of mercy, will have to pass through the door of My justice...
— (Diary of St. Faustina, 1146)"

💬 QUOTE OF THE DAY

"God condemns each of us to be a pure spirit, inhabitant of a celestial world and fully happy." Haroldo Dutra Dias

Watch with English subtitles 

THE PENAL CODE OF THE FUTURE LIFE — Allan Kardec — Lecture delivered by 

Judge Haroldo Dutra Dias

GEMINI AI : 

Based on Judge Haroldo Dutra Dias's lecture on the "Penal Code of the Future Life" from Allan Kardec's work (Heaven and Hell), I have prepared the complete and structured article for publication on your blog, containing the analysis, topic indexing, and cited literary references.

Divine Justice and the Penal Code of the Future Life: An Educational Perspective of Existence

We often experience, without realizing it under old dogmatic remnants, the idea that the universe is governed by a system of severe punishments and eternal castigations. However, when we analyze the Spiritist Doctrine—especially one of the most profound chapters of Heaven and Hell by Allan Kardec—we are invited to an inner revolution: to understand God's justice not as a tribunal of vengeance, but as a perfect system of learning, transformation, and evolution of the soul.

In an inspiring lecture, judge and speaker Haroldo Dutra Dias unveils the true meaning of the Penal Code of the Future Life, demonstrating that all pain has a strictly educational purpose and that no suffering is eternal.

📌 Topics Covered in the Lecture

The True Meaning of the Penal Code of the Future Life: Understanding future punishments and joys in light of spiritual progress.

Free Will and the Educational System: The journey of the spirit from innocence to moral autonomy and the natural consequences of its choices.

Inexperience versus Incongruence: The distinction between erring due to a lack of life experience and erring due to inner dissonance (when we know what is correct, but our way of being still tunes in with the mistake).

The Triad of Divine Justice: The three fundamental pillars for the rebalancing of the soul:

Repentance (Teshuvah): The conscious return to the correct path.

Reparation: The active commitment to do good to those we have harmed.

Expiation: The process of purifying remaining imperfections through life's educational filters.

Trials and Expiations: The difference between pedagogical training to gain experience (trial) and the purification of deeply rooted imperfections (expiation).

The Role of Relationships: How Divine Providence uses family and social bonds—often marked by past redemptions—as instruments of moral improvement.

The Ultimate Goal of Divine Law: The absolute inevitability of evolution, since God's supreme objective is to lead each spirit to full happiness.

🔍 Analytical Summary of the Presentation

1. Evil as a "Drop in the Bucket" for the Creator

Starting the reflection, the speaker recalls that spirits are created simple and ignorant, gradually conquering free will. When interacting with life, the spirit experiences the consequences of its decisions. Citing Emmanuel in question 132 of The Comforter, the speaker highlights that, for God, evil in its essence is transitory, a "drop in the bucket", because Divine Wisdom's main concern is not the punishment of error, but learning.

2. The Two Types of Error: 

Inexperience and Incongruence

Human beings can produce evil from two distinct perspectives:

Due to inexperience: 

Lack of life experience and moral training. The remedy for this evil is the accumulation of flight hours on the path of good, through trials.

Due to incongruence: Occurs when the individual already possesses intellectual enlightenment, knows what must be done, but their deep will still clings to error—generating an internal dissonance between the intellect and the way of being.

3. The Triad of the Law: Repentance, Reparation, and Expiation

Unlike human justice (which focuses on social control and punitive isolation), divine justice acts within the core of the way of being:

Repentance (Teshuvah): In its biblical root, Teshuvah literally means return. It is not limited to passive sorrow on a deathbed, but to the lucid decision to make a U-turn on the wrong road and proceed in the correct direction.

Reparation: Consists of doing good to those we have hurt. Those who do not repair their debts due to bad will or weakness meet the same companions of the journey in future existences to redeem bonds of affection and rebalance.

Expiation: These are physical and moral sufferings that function as "purifying filters". As long as there are traces of imperfection in the way of thinking, feeling, and acting, the soul remains subject to these instruments of purification until it reaches purity.

📚 Literary and Cultural References Cited in the Lecture

Allan Kardec — Heaven and Hell (The Penal Code of the Future Life)

Allan Kardec — The Spirits' Book

Emmanuel (through Francisco Cândido Xavier) — The Comforter (Question 132)

Humberto de Campos (spirit) — Good News

André Luiz (spirit) — Between Earth and Sky

Bert Hellinger — Concept regarding bonds and partnerships of misfortune

Book of Genesis (Chapter 2 — Universal cosmic fluid and the divine presence)

Gospels — Hebrew concept of Teshuvah

Ariano Suassuna — The Compasionate's Auto (Illustrative example used in the presentation)

Arthur Schopenhauer — The porcupine analogy applied to human relationships

💬 Highlight Quote: 

"God condemns each of us to be a pure spirit, inhabitant of a celestial world and fully happy. Accept it because it hurts less." — Haroldo Dutra Dias

Watch the full lecture on YouTube via the official link: https://youtu.be/6DmNjOdkSyo.

Video views will be stored in YouTube History. Additionally, your data will be stored and used by YouTube in accordance with the platform's Terms of Service.

Video views will be stored in YouTube History. Additionally, your data will be stored and used by YouTube in accordance with the platform's Terms of Service.

Com base na palestra do Juiz Haroldo Dutra Dias sobre o "Código Penal da Vida Futura" da obra de Allan Kardec (O Céu e o Inferno), elaborei o artigo completo e estruturado para publicação no seu blog, contendo a análise, a indexação dos tópicos e as referências literárias citadas.

A Justiça Divina e o Código Penal da Vida Futura: Uma Perspectiva Educativa da Existência

Vivenciamos, muitas vezes sem perceber, sob velhos resquícios dogmáticos, a ideia de que o universo é regido por um sistema de punições severas e castigos eternos. 

Contudo, quando analisamos a Doutrina Espírita — em especial um dos capítulos mais profundos de O Céu e o Inferno, de Allan Kardec —, somos convidados a uma revolução íntima: compreender a justiça de Deus não como um tribunal de vindita, mas como um sistema perfeito de aprendizado, transformação e evolução da alma.

Em uma palestra inspiradora, o juiz e conferencista Haroldo Dutra Dias desvenda o verdadeiro sentido do Código Penal da Vida Futura, demonstrando que toda dor possui um propósito estritamente educativo e que nenhum sofrimento é eterno.

📌 Tópicos Abordados na Palestra

O Verdadeiro Significado do Código Penal da Vida Futura: Compreensão das penas e gozos futuros à luz do progresso espiritual.

Livre-Arbítrio e o Sistema Educativo: A jornada do espírito desde a inocência até a autonomia moral e as consequências naturais de suas escolhas.

Inexperiência versus Incongruência: A distinção entre errar por falta de vivência e errar por dissonância íntima (quando sabemos o que é correto, mas o nosso modo de ser ainda se sintoniza com o equívoco).

A Tríade da Justiça Divina: Os três pilares fundamentais para o reequilíbrio da alma:

Arrependimento (Teshuvá): O retorno consciente ao caminho correto.

Reparação: O compromisso ativo de fazer o bem àqueles a quem prejudicamos.

Expiação: O processo de purificação das imperfeições remanescentes através dos filtros educativos da vida.

Provas e Expiações: A diferença entre o treinamento pedagógico para ganho de experiência (prova) e a depuração de imperfeições enraizadas (expiação).

O Papel dos Relacionamentos: Como a Providência Divina utiliza os laços familiares e sociais — muitas vezes marcados por antigos resgates — como instrumentos de aprimoramento moral.

A Meta Final da Lei Divina: A absoluta inevitabilidade da evolução, visto que o objetivo supremo de Deus é conduzir cada espírito à felicidade plena.

🔍 Resumo Analítico da Exposição

1. O Mal como um "Zero à Esquerda" para o Criador

Iniciando a reflexão, o expositor recorda que os espíritos são criados simples e ignorantes, conquistando gradualmente o livre-arbítrio. Ao interagir com a vida, o espírito experimenta as consequências de suas decisões. 

Citando Emmanuel na questão 132 de O Consolador, o palestrante destaca que, para Deus, o mal em sua essência é transitório, um "zero à esquerda", pois a grande preocupação da Sabedoria Divina não é a punição do erro, mas o aprendizado.

2. Os Dois Tipos de Erro: Inexperiência e Incongruência

O ser humano pode produzir o mal sob duas ótricas distintas:

Por inexperiência: Falta de vivência e treino moral. O remédio para este mal é a acumulação de horas de voo na senda do bem, através das provas.

Por incongruência: Ocorre quando o indivíduo já possui esclarecimento intelectual, sabe o que deve fazer, mas sua vontade profunda ainda se apega ao erro — gerando uma dissonância interna entre o intelecto e o modo de ser.

3. A Tríade da Lei: Arrependimento, Reparação e Expiação

Diferente da justiça humana (que foca no controle social e no isolamento punitivo), a justiça divina atua no íntimo do modo de ser:

Arrependimento (Teshuvá): 

Na raiz bíblica, Teshuvá significa literalmente retorno. Não se resume a um pesar passivo no leito de morte, mas à decisão lúcida de dar meia-volta na estrada equivocada e prosseguir na direção correta.

Reparação: 

Consiste em fazer o bem àqueles a quem ferimos. Quem não repara seus débitos por má vontade ou fraqueza, reencontra os mesmos companheiros de jornada em existências futuras para resgatar os laços de afeto e reequilíbrio.

Expiação: 

São os sofrimentos físicos e morais que funcionam como "filtros purificadores". 

Enquanto houver vestígios de imperfeição no modo de pensar, sentir e agir, a alma permanece sujeita a esses instrumentos de depuração até alcançar a pureza.

📚 Referências Literárias e Culturais Citadas na Palestra

Allan Kardec — O Céu e o Inferno (O Código Penal da Vida Futura)

Allan Kardec — O Livro dos Espíritos

Emmanuel ( Francisco Cândido Xavier) — O Consolador (Questão 132)

Humberto de Campos (espírito) — Boa Nova

André Luiz (espírito) — Entre a Terra e o Céu

Bert Hellinger — Conceito sobre vínculos e parcerias de infortúnio

Livro de Gênesis (Capítulo 2 — O fluido cósmico universal e a presença divina)

Evangelhos — Conceito hebraico de Teshuvá

Ariano Suassuna — O Auto da Compadecida (Exemplo ilustrativo utilizado na exposição)

Arthur Schopenhauer — A analogia dos porcos-espinhos aplicada aos relacionamentos humanos

💬 Frase de Destaque:

 "Deus condena cada um de nós a ser um espírito puro, habitante de um mundo celeste e plenamente feliz. Aceita que dói menos." — Haroldo Dutra Dias

Assista à palestra completa no YouTube através do link oficial: 

https://youtu.be/6DmNjOdkSyo?is=fhojUVRPaJKYhToG.

THE PENAL CODE OF THE FUTURE LIFE — Allan Kardec — Lecture delivered by  Judge Haroldo Dutra Dias

Abstract by the Author :  

Do we live in a universe governed by punishments or by a perfect process of spiritual education?

In this lecture, Haroldo Dutra Dias presents a new perspective on one of the most profound chapters of Heaven and Hell, by Allan Kardec: the Penal Code of Future Life. 

Instead of a vision based on divine punishments, we are invited to understand God's justice as a perfect system of learning, transformation, and evolution of the soul.

Throughout the presentation, Haroldo explains that suffering is not born from a punishment imposed by God, but from the spirit's own imperfections. 

Every life experience has an educational purpose, leading us to moral improvement through repentance (return to the correct path), reparation of the evil done, and expiation, understood as the process of purifying the imperfections that still remain in our way of thinking, feeling, and acting.

The lecture differentiates errors committed due to a lack of experience from those born of inner incongruence—when we know what is right, but are not yet able to live that knowledge. 

From this distinction, Haroldo demonstrates why some trials seem to repeat throughout reincarnations and how Divine Providence uses each relationship, each difficulty, and each challenge as instruments of spiritual growth.

With humorous examples, references to the Spiritist Codification, the teachings of Emmanuel, Chico Xavier, and Bert Hellinger, the lecture reveals that all pain has an educational purpose and that no suffering is eternal. 

The objective of Divine Law is never to condemn, but to lead each spirit to full happiness.

If this reflection touched your heart, share this video and help more people understand the beauty of Divine Justice according to Spiritism.

📌 TOPICS COVERED 

🔹 The true meaning of the Penal Code of Future Life. 

🔹 Free will and the educational process of spiritual evolution. 

🔹 The difference between error due to inexperience and error due to incongruence. 

🔹 Suffering as a natural consequence of imperfections. 

🔹 The Law of Love as the foundation of Divine Justice. 

🔹 The difference between human justice and divine justice. 

🔹 The true biblical meaning of repentance (Teshuvah). 

🔹 Repentance as a return to the correct path. 

🔹 Reparation: doing good to those we have harmed.

🔹 Expiation as a process of purifying imperfections. 

🔹 Trials and expiations according to the Spiritist Doctrine. 

🔹 The role of relationships in moral improvement. 

🔹 The repetition of reincarnational experiences. 

🔹 Reincarnational planning and the types of trials and expiations. 

🔹 The ultimate goal of Divine Law: to form pure spirits.

📚 CITED REFERENCES

📖 Allan Kardec — Heaven and Hell (Penal Code of Future Life)

📖 Allan Kardec — The Spirits' Book 

📖 Emmanuel — The Comforter (Question 132) 

📖 Humberto de Campos — Good News 

📖 André Luiz — Between Earth and Sky 

📖 Chico Xavier 

📖 Bert Hellinger 

📖 Book of Genesis (Chapter 2) 

📖 Gospels (biblical concept of Teshuvah) 

📖 Ariano Suassuna — The Compasionate's Auto (example used) 

📖 Arthur Schopenhauer (porcupine analogy)

💬 QUOTE OF THE DAY

"God condemns each of us to be a pure spirit, inhabitant of a celestial world and fully happy."

🔎 KEYWORDS

"penal code of future life, heaven and hell, allan kardec, haroldo dutra dias, divine justice, law of cause and effect, repentance, expiation, reparation, teshuvah, spiritist doctrine, spiritism, emmanuel, chico xavier, the comforter, good news, between earth and sky, spiritual evolution, trials and expiations, free will, suffering, reincarnation, law of love, spiritual growth, gospel, spiritist philosophy, life after death, education of the soul, forgiveness, moral transformation"

Summary by YouTube AI

In this lecture, Haroldo Dutra Dias proposes a deep reflection on the Penal Code of Future Life, a chapter of the work Heaven and Hell by Allan Kardec, from the perspective of the divine educational system and not a system of eternal punishments.

Key Points of the Presentation:

Error and Learning: Suffering is not a punishment imposed by God, but the natural consequence of the spirit's imperfections. 

Error can occur due to inexperience (lack of training) or incongruence (when there is an internal conflict between what one knows and what one desires) (3:28 - 9:53). 

Why is suffering called temporary?

The speaker states that all suffering is temporary because it is the direct consequence of our imperfections (14:43 - 15:03). 

Since the goal of Divine Justice is not eternal punishment, but learning and purification, suffering remains only as long as there are vestiges of imperfection that need to be purified (34:44 - 35:12, 40:00 - 40:47). 

As soon as the lesson is learned or the flaw is repaired, the reason for expiation ceases to exist and suffering ceases (43:00 - 43:19).

The Triad of Evolution: For each fault, divine justice offers a mechanism for rebalancing:

1. Repentance (Teshuvah): The return to the correct path (22:46 - 24:42). 

2. Reparation: The commitment to do good to those whom we have caused harm (28:49 - 34:42). 

3. Expiation: The process of purifying imperfections, which uses relationships and challenges as educational "filters" (39:36 - 44:02). 

The Nature of Divine Justice: 

Divine Providence does not seek to isolate or punish, but to refine souls until they become pure spirits. Trials and expiations are, therefore, instruments of moral improvement (47:08 - 55:24).

The speaker concludes by emphasizing that the ultimate goal of creation is full happiness: "God condemns each of us to be a pure spirit."

What is the difference between expiação (expiation) and prova (trial)?

According to Haroldo Dutra Dias's lecture, the distinction between trial and expiation is related to the educational purpose of suffering and the spirit's stage of learning (47:08 - 48:07):

Trial: 

Its main objective is the training and development of the spirit. It serves to confer experience to those who commit errors due to inexperience (lack of training or life experience). It is like a pedagogical exercise to strengthen the soul.

Expiation: 

Its focus is purification. It acts on the imperfections that still remain in the spirit, functioning as a "purifying filter" (44:50 - 46:25). Expiatory suffering exists as long as there are traces of imperfection that need to be refined for the spirit to reach plenitude (40:00 - 43:19).

In short, trial prepares you for the future (gaining experience), while expiation helps clear the past (refining imperfections).

What causes error due to incongruence?

According to Haroldo Dutra Dias, error due to incongruence does not stem from a lack of knowledge or enlightenment, but from an internal dissonance within the spirit (7:37 - 9:07).

The main causes of this error include:

Conflict between wanting and not wanting: 

The individual possesses knowledge about what is correct, but their deep desire or yearning is still aligned with the error (7:49 - 8:34). 

Identification with the way of being: 

The error becomes part of the person's identity; they think, feel, and act in a mistaken way because they identify with this pattern, even knowing what should be done (9:11 - 9:53). 

Difficulty of transformation: 

It is not enough just to enlighten the intellect, since the person is already enlightened. The central challenge is to convert this dissonance into consonance, changing the way of being entirely (9:56 - 10:42).

What does Teshuvá mean in spiritism?

In the context of Haroldo Dutra Dias's lecture, the Hebrew term Teshuvá is presented as the true biblical meaning of repentance (22:46 - 23:47).

Unlike a passive view of merely feeling sorrow for a mistake, Teshuvá literally means return:

Return to the correct path: It is the conscious decision to change route. If you are on a wrong road, true repentance is not just lamenting the journey, but making the return (Teshuvá) to move forward in the right direction (23:00 - 24:00). 

Inner change: 

It involves a real change in the way of thinking, feeling, and acting. It is the moment when the spirit recognizes that its previous choices led it to a path of misfortune and decides, on its own, to alter its conduct (24:00 - 24:42).

Therefore, in Spiritism, Teshuvá is not magical forgiveness received externally, but an active process of moral renewal where the individual assumes responsibility for their evolution.

https://youtu.be/6DmNjOdkSyo?is=fhojUVRPaJKYhToG

REFERENCES:

FAUSTINA, Santa. Diário: A Misericórdia Divina na minha alma**. 2. ed. Curitiba: Congregação das Irmãs de Nossa Senhora da Misericórdia, 1995. Disponível em: https://www.divinamisericordia.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Diario-Santa-Faustina-Completo.pdf.

FAUSTINA, Saint. Diary: Divine Mercy in My Soul. 2nd ed. Curitiba: Congregation of the Sisters of Our Lady of Mercy, 1995. Available at: https://www.divinamisericordia.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Diario-Santa-Faustina-Completo.pdf.

KARDEC, Allan. Heaven and Hell: or Divine Justice According to Spiritism. Organization by Claudio Damasceno Ferreira Junior. Porto Alegre: BesouroBox, 2020. Available at: https://pt.scribd.com/document/781824137/O-Ceu-e-o-Inferno-Allan-Kardec-e-Claudio-Damasceno-1.

KARDEC, Allan. The Spirits' Book. Translation by Guillon Ribeiro. 93rd ed. Brasília: Brazilian Spiritist Federation, 2013. Available at: https://www.oconsolador.com.br/linkfixo/bibliotecavirtual/O%20Livro%20dos%20Espiritos.pdf.

XAVIER, Francisco Cândido. The Comforter. Through the Spirit Emmanuel. 1st ed. Brasília: Brazilian Spiritist Federation, 1940. Available at: https://pt.scribd.com/document/161452361/XAVIER-Francisco-Candido-O-Consolador-Emmanuel.

XAVIER, Francisco Cândido. Good News. Through the Spirit Humberto de Campos. Rio de Janeiro: Brazilian Spiritist Federation, 1941. Available at: https://pt.scribd.com/document/345198428/XAVIER-Francisco-Candido-Boa-Nova-Humberto-de-Campos.